I try to keep my politics out of how I view an ad, and while I know that's not really possible (our unconscious brains are constantly providing commentary on the world in the form of "feelings" that bubble up into consciousness), I at least try not to judge an ad on where its message falls on the political spectrum. [youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZraskhJVKeA&feature=player_embedded]
With this ad though it's really tough. Not sure why, but I hate this ad. It's an obvious parody of the Apple Mac/PC ads, but it's a really bad parody. It has none of the wit or whimsy that makes those ads so clever and cutting. In the original ads, the PC guy is likable, here m the Government run health care plan guy is especially annoying, and even the girl is annoying. I don't really find either of them likable at all. The acting is pretty weak too.
(Here's a tip about actors, always find people who can act first, then worry about if they "look" the part. I've seem more bad casting because someone who can't act is given a part because they look like
But I worry, is it the message of the ad that rubs me the wrong way, or the messenger, the ad itself? Am I just coming up with a rationale to make sense of my feeling of hate?
I don't know (and probably can't know without years of therapy), but bad execution really rubs me the wrong way, and this ad feels like they ripped off the form without really having an understanding of how it worked. It has the rhythm of the original, the look (though it's a pretty weak green screen floor), but it's a little like listening to a schizophrenic talk, he uses real words, but put together they're gibberish.
And on top of that it ends so abruptly.