iPod v. iPod

in

In my last post I show the iconic iPod ad.  Well before that one there was this one: [youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mE_bDNaYAr8]

Well it's not bad.  But it ain't iconic and doesn't inspire the same feelings as the what we've come to know as iPod ads.

Everyone can misfire once in a while, even Apple.  When you think about this ad versus the "Hey Mama" which one do you think better represents what you think of as Apple in your mind?